Depressed about the state of the mobile industry

k800

k800
Originally uploaded by smstextnews.

I dunno, now and again. Geez. It all gets a little bit… limited.

There’s only so much annoyance that I can take, before I just have to switch off and stare at the wall to calm down.

And today, this evening, my annoyance reached it’s zenith.

I am beyond annoyed, beyond wound up, beyond recovery, at least this evening.

First let me tip my hat to Olav at eSato for his K800 review — I was hunting around for a good picture and found it there.

Here’s the issue.

I was on the train back to Billericay this evening. It was packed full of people because of another glorious ‘woops’ by One Railway, our local and occasionally inept railway company.

I was standing in the doorway, leaning against the partition and across from me was a chap, who, sensibly, had sat down against the opposite partition by the door.

He had his headphones in. I recognised them as Sony Ericsson ones.

I followed the wire down and saw he was using an K800.

Interesting.

He was properly using it. It’s always nice to see folk properly using their technology. He was texting away, bit of internet, and listening to his music the whole journey.

So, I was pleased.

But then my eye moved to his headphones and the flippin’ great lump of plastic plugged into the bottom of his phone.

And that’s when I had enough.

See this picture above? See the headset, bottom right? That’s what I’m talking about.

Ugly.

Plugged into the K800, it’s massively ugly.

In fact, it increases the size of the phone by about, what, 15%?

And it meant the guy couldn’t easily lean the phone anywhere. The increased length also meant that, in this chap’s case, he couldn’t easily fit it into his pocket.

Stupid.

Absolutely stupid.

This is where I just lost it in my mind. What mobile company, what MUSIC related mobile company releases such trash?

What company releases a MUSIC PHONE, whose strategy is almost ENTIRELY ABOUT MUSIC in the context of the huge range of Walkman phones…… gaah.

No I can’t even be bothered to write. It really does wind me up.

Why is there no normal headphone jack?

Don’t give me the rubbish about it being difficult to fit into the specification. Or there being a size problem.

If you are looking for proof of just how STUPID the mobile phone industry is at times, there you go.

Of course, it’s not just Sony Ericsson.

What muppet. What ABSOLUTE MUPPET of a designer allows a handset out the factory gate that apparently PLAYS MUSIC but doesn’t allow you to LISTEN TO MUSIC with normal headphones?

I’m not at home to arguments about ‘well, the handsfree kit needs..’ or anything like that.

If there’s a problem about getting a microphone feed in through the headphone jack, innovate and make it work.

If you’re trying to make your devices into music players, why are you shipping them with SHIT headphones and with MASSIVE add-ons.

I got an adapter for my Nokia E61 a while ago, so I could use normal headphones on it and listen to my MP3s.

You know what? I used it twice.

Why?

Embarrassment.

It increased the total size of my device and looked COMPLETELY UGLY.

Now. Don’t give me the ugliness argument, ‘it’s functional’. It’s obviously all about style, or we’d all be walking around with Nokia 3300s.

Somebody who knows more than me, please explain the logic behind shipping expensive handsets PURPOSE BUILT to play music that EVEN HAVE BUTTONS ON’EM FOR PLAY, PAUSE, AND SO ON — why are they shipped with huge plugs?

Or worse: Why do you have to go and buy a STUPID adapter that is HUGE?

It’s ridiculous.

I’ve had enough of it.

I really have.

Years ago, when you had to buy headphones as an additional purchase, fine. Fine. That’s fine for them to look rubbish — like an after thought, designed by the tea boy.

But now: When music is a core service, a core offering, why is the planet still offered total dross?

It was REALLY annoying seeing the Apple iPhone with a normal headphone jack. I’m looking at it and going, ‘wow, that’s cool’. Like a caveman being shown a lighter.

It ain’t rocket science. And whatever the arguments, whatever the apparent justifications from the manufacturers, whatever the strategies, they’re wrong.

I’m beyond annoyance with it all.

Ok. And

…….

Breathe…………………….

WOOOOOOSAHHHH

WOOOOOOOSAAAAAAAAAAHHH

About Ewan

Ewan is Founder and Editor of Mobile Industry Review. He writes about a wide variety of industry issues and is usually active on Twitter most days. You can read more about him or reach him with these details.
  • http://phranticsnr.wordpress.com Daniel

    Nokia’s N91 has a standard 3.5mm stereo headset jack too, doesn’t it? Anyway, I think what the world really needs here is a standard, integrated plug type for stereo audio plus microphone. That’s why we need the bloody great adaptor cable junk – it contains the microphone for using it as a handsfree. It really wouldn’t be hard to modify a standard 3.5mm stereo plug to have a third wire in it for the microphone – it’s been done before. Just not by a phone company.

  • ewan

    I was pleased to see that in the N91 Daniel. You’re right, we need a standard!

  • http://invalid.name Dan Lane

    One of the few redeeming features of the HTC Universal (XDA Exec, Orange SPV M5000 etc) was that it charging and syncing was handled via a bog standard mini-USB port.. just like in my BlackBerry… I only carried one charger for both devices, and if I was without a power supply I could top up the battery from my laptop.

    Manufacturers need to stop leeching the profits from official aftermarket chargers and just go with an industry standard connector for syncing and charging (mini-USB!)… to that end, even the guys at Google have pleaded with the industry for this!

    I believe the E62 (the crippled US version of the E61 – no 3G or WiFi) has a mini-USB port and a 2.5mm headphone jack (not quite as perfect as a 3.5mm jack but an acceptable improvement over that proprietary pop-port nonesense) but it also has the new Nokia CA-44 power socket so I don’t know if it charges through the USB socket as well.

  • http://phranticsnr.wordpress.com Daniel

    Motorola’s switch to mini-USB is nothing short of brilliant. I can’t stand the rest of Motorola’s phones, but the mini-USB thing is great. All HTCs are using the mini-USB thing as well now too, as you point out.

    What is the phone charger/handsfree market worth? Are manufacturers really going to lose out in any major way if they convert to standardised accessory plugs? Surely not – genuine phone-brand headphones can get pretty exxy (it’s worse than buying new razor blades at 3/4 the cost of a new razor), but there are plenty of perfectly good yum-cha accessories available already, so I’m not seeing a reason for these proprietory plugs and ports?

  • http://invalid.name Dan Lane

    They must see the value in branded aftermarket accessories otherwise there is no logical reason to use such proprietary connectors. Even if there isn’t a huge loss to be made (I mean, who doesn’t have a dozen Nokia chargers in a drawer somewhere?) there may be a perceived value chain hidden away in a senior exec’s mind somewhere.

    I think Nokia are slowly making steps in the right direction but I doubt Sony Ericsson will ever get there (Sony being a huge perpetrator of proprietary devices – Memory Stick anyone?).

    As for Motorola… YES!, I’d completely forgotten they had made the switch, unfortunately they still release solid (and recently, very well designed) hardware and ruin the package by having terrible software. Moto’s involvement in the newly announced LiMo foundation may actually help them fix this problem (although we’ve seen previous linux-on-mobile initiatives before that haven’t gone anywhere)… but anyway, I’m rambling now.

  • Phone shop guy

    The only thing about the N91 is that the handset itself is the largest handset ever to be made in the world. It cannot fit into any normal size pocket and what doesn’t appeal to most people is the fact that they would have to carry it around in a laptop bag.

    I completely agree with this headphones issue. I have a w810 and I have used the headphones once because of the daft add-on. While I know that the add-on has a 3.5mm heaphone jack at the end of it, its still an absolute arse ache to carry both wires and then to wire it up to listen to music.

    Also, put your hands up if you hate:

    “Please insert the handsfree. The cord works as the radio antenna”

    *puts his hand up*

    Integrated FM antenna? Is it so hard to ask? We’ve got phones without pull-out aerials, why not phones without wired radio antenna?

    And an afterthought, If the N95 needs a 7 tonne satellite dish attachment for the GPS, i’m not going to be happy…

Switch to our mobile site