Is it time to subscribe to a printer service from HP?

Ever since my dad brought home an...

What’s the best way of buying a phone today?

How did you buy your latest phone?...

MWC: What device highlights did you miss?

So, early last week I predicted that...

Morgan Mullooly of Analysys Mason gives us a viewpoint on the EE/Ofcom/Vodafone spectrum debacle

Further to my earlier post, here’s some rather useful perspective from Analysys Mason’s spectrum specialist Morgan Mullooly.

  • Ofcom’s decision is really rather startling – if not completely unexpected. Although Ofcom gave an initial informal knee- jerk head-nod to the proposal [to permit EE to use its 1800MHz spectrum for LTE] when it was first raised, it postponed making a decision at that time due to the overwhelming objection to the plan by Everything Everywhere’s competitors.
  • However, the inertia in actually getting to the 800MHz/2600MHz auction (because of the challenge of getting the rules right, dealing with potential interference mitigation issues, and keeping five mobile operators happy) seemed to be making Ofcom impatient and its initial receptiveness to the Everything Everywhere proposal seemed to betrayed that impatient attitude. This was borne out in today’s decision.
  • This decision gives Everything Everywhere a first mover advantage of at least three months on its rivals Vodafone, O2, and Three.
  • While refarming of spectrum (the granting of approval to allow the use of an alternate transmission or modulation standard within a particular band – i.e. allowing 2G spectrum to be used for 4G) is of course a sensible endeavour (it engenders both technological efficiency and socio-economic benefits), Ofcom could have been more judicious and allowed refarming after the auction. This would have allowed all operators to deploy LTE (4G) on a level playing field.
  • The unexpectedness of this decision is compounded in light of the litigious cloud that has been hanging over UK spectrum policy making since LTE first came onto the agenda.
  • It is possible that some of Everything Everywhere’s rivals might launch a legal challenge against the decision. Vodafone in particular has adopted a very rueful, if not adversarial tone. Its press release, which uses the phrases ‘bizarre’, ‘careless disregard’, ‘refusal to properly regard the competitive distortion’ ends with the lament ‘all that stands in our way right now is the regulator’. However the operators are expecting the auction to perhaps take place in December 2012/Q1-2013 so it may not be worthwhile to pursue legal action.
  • While there is no hard set date for the auction, any litigation could potentially push the auction back further than three or four months. This could have the effect of lengthening Everything Everywhere’s first mover advantage (which begins in exactly three weeks) and its ability to capitalise on market share.

Very useful that, thank you Morgan!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Recently Published

Is it time to subscribe to a printer service from HP?

Ever since my dad brought home an HP LaserJet printer (version 3, if memory serves), I have been printing with an HP. Over the...

What’s the best way of buying a phone today?

How did you buy your latest phone? I'm asking because I'm thinking about what I should be doing. When I was living in Oman, I...

MWC: What device highlights did you miss?

So, early last week I predicted that next to nothing from Mobile World Congress would break through into the mainstream media. I was right,...

How Wireless Will Pave the Path to Neobank Profitability

I'm delighted to bring you an opinion piece from Rafa Plantier at Gigs.com. I think it's particularly relevant given the recent eSIM news from...

An end of an era: Vodafone UK turns off 3G services

I thought it was worthwhile highlighting this one from the Vodafone UK team. For so long - for what feels like years, seeing the...

Mobile World Congress: Did the mainstream media notice?

I resolved this year to make sure I wrote something - anything - about Mobile World Congress, the huge mobile industry trade show taking...