Informa Telecoms & Media’s Principal Analyst, Thomas Wehmeier, reckons the news today from Ofcom is rather positive:
Ofcom’s decision to allow Everything Everywhere to use 4G LTE in its 1800MHz spectrum is a major milestone for the UK mobile market. The timing of today’s ruling now opens the door to the arrival of 4G in Britain from as early as September this year – a welcome leap forward given the painful delays that have beset the auction of the 4G spectrum bands at 800 and 2600.
Today’s news should be seen as a strong vindication of Everything Everywhere’s bold decision to invest heavily in readying the ground for LTE without having the regulatory clarity that would have mitigated any such risks. Ever since Olaf Swantee took the helm at the UK’s largest mobile operator, the company has been focused on establishing itself as the UK’s leading high-speed mobile broadband network. This has not only seen EE spend large sums in modernising their 2G and 3G networks, but also invest quietly to fully prepare their nationwide network for the arrival of LTE. This meant swapping out old radio equipment and laying the “backhaul” infrastructure needed to carry large flows of data up and down the country.
EE now has a golden opportunity to establish an early lead in the UK’s 4G market, but it will only be able to exploit this window if it is able to build a successful launch strategy. The most successful 4G operators globally, including in the world’s most advanced 4G markets of the US and Korea, have been those that came out of the traps quickly and built their LTE networks out extensively.
Another critical task that lies ahead for EE will be to convince the world’s leading device manufacturers to build smartphones for their network. You can build the network, but without the right devices the customers cannot and will not come.
There are already a number of networks in commercial operation in countries such as Australia and Korea that use the same frequency as EE, but most smartphone makers have preferred to focus on building their devices for the larger networks of operators in the US, Japan and Korea that run on different frequencies. The new iPhone will almost certainly support 4G LTE when it is unveiled next month, but it is much less certain that 1800 will be amongst the frequencies supported. It is a huge “if”, but if the new iPhone were to support EE’s band it would undoubtedly be the much-needed spark to ignite Britain’s heavily-delayed 4G market.
The ruling issued today applies to the full chunk of 1800MHz spectrum that Everything Everywhere owns in the UK, including the 2x15MHz that it is being forced to divest as a result of conditions imposed on the Orange-T-Mobile merger by the European Commission. The clarity on the potential use of that spectrum will provide fresh impetus to the sale negotiations with Hutchison 3G (3) the clear favourite to land the spectrum. The sale must be finalised by 30 September 2013, but news reports suggest that sales talks are at an advanced stage, meaning the UK could conceivably see two 4G networks up and running before the main auction event is finalised.
But as is always the risk in the fiercely competitive and ligitation-prone UK market, it’s possible that Ofcom’s decision could be delayed by legal challenges. The risk for the UK other’s mobile operators is that dragging this through the courts could serve only to further delay the timing of the upcoming auction and thereby pause their own plans to launch 4G.
I think Thomas makes a good point — this is certainly a milestone. However I don’t necessarily reckon the other operators have been standing about doing nothing. Allowing Everything Everywhere to steal a march doesn’t seem that useful except for them.